God help me, here we go...
Well, that opening score just never gets old, does it?
I like the title. Campy in a similar fashion to ESB. Unfortunately, it doesn't actually make a lot of sense for the movie, does it?
A pan up. Nice.
Not showing Padme's face right away is too obvious.
I like the foggy setting as they land. Good, ominous tone.
She's only a senator now. Why does she need a decoy?
Already the red, Imperial guards? A bit soon for my taste, but they look so awesome that I'll allow it.
You're a Jedi, Yoda. Why are there any warm feelings in your distant, mutant heart?
Sam Jackson is a great actor... yet he can't deliver a single line well in these films. Lack of imagination or is the direction just that bad? My bet is on the latter.
Hayden really isn't that bad... but the writing really is.
Ugh, stop saying Ani.
To be fair, she IS fucking beautiful. Anakin has needs.
Zem's speeder design is awesome. I have imagine myself in something similar many times.
Covered the cameras. And then R2 turns off. This is absurd. Who would have fucking thought they'd try the giant window?
I like the exchange between Anakin and Obi about dreams. Seems almost genuine.
Bugs for murder? You're already at the window, dude. Just throw a fucking thermal detonator in there.
You're a DROID R2, you don't need to sleep. Lazy bitch.
Anakin is really that poor a judge of character?
I know it doesn't make sense that Obi jumps out of the window... but this sequence is fun enough that I get over it. Makes me think of a Grand Theft Auto: Coruscant game. I really enjoy this whole sequence. Anakin's jump out of the speeder is the single event in the whole prequel trilogy that makes him seem cool.
"That was short." Then why include it, George?
I'm not sure why Anakin sticks his lightsaber into the cockpit. Must have a deathwish. Fucking emo teenagers, man.
A girl in a thong. In Star Wars. I mean, it is the underbelly, nightclub world of Coruscant, so hey, who knows what those chicks wear.
A changling, eh? Like Tommy in Rugrats? Kudos to anyone who gets that.
Will he really go home and think his life? Maybe he'll just get home and realize he's fucked for not having sold enough deathsticks that night. He won't be able to pay rent and will end up dead. Great message, George.
Hey guys, maybe follow that dude with the jetpack. Maybe he knows something.
Right, send the hormonely charged teenager with the hotty senator to a remote location. You Jedi are not great judges of character.
His abilities have made him arrogant? How about you SHOW us some of that instead of just claiming it's there.
Sloppy writing. Jar Jar a senator?
Whine about your life. Bitches love whining.
Yes, then give her the rapey eyes. Bitches love rapey eyes.
Another situation where I wish I could read R2's mind. I'm pretty sure they sent him (it?) as the actual protection. R2 doesn't fuck around.
Fuck yeah Jawa Juice (SHOT!)
Jango doesn't seem terribly smart to use weapons from the secret planet he's stationed on.
Poor CG on Dex, but the voice acting isn't too bad.
Jedi Library. It isn't all just stored on a thumb drive? Huh.
Decent acting from Hayden in this scene. Well, until the shit about dreaming about Padme. Though, to be fair, I doubt Jedi get a lot of practice with the ladies.
Kids with lightsabers. Yeah, that seems like a great idea. Also, Plinket nailed this one. Obi improved this blind exercise in ANH, but suddenly they use it as an official training. Lame.
The stars pull towards it? Fuck off. Stars are not that close together. Gravity wouldn't mean jack shit.
YT-1300 freighters on Naboo. I'll allow it.
They don't have rolling suitcases in this universe?
Jedi Starfighter, you so sexy. Early A-Wing. Mmmmm.
Ocean planet... actually, that one makes sense. The one planet I wouldn't want to live on, but a cool idea.
This planet reeks of A.I.
Not sure why Obi fakes it here. Why wouldn't he just ask honest questions? These guys don't seem to be in on some insidious (heh) scheme, so they would likely answer the questions of a Jedi.
Oh, this lovely "sand" speech. 100 dollars to ANY man who manges to woo a woman with this. She has to know know the origin.
As much as I love the "Theed Invasion" piece, it doesn't make a lot of sense for it to be recalled right now. Good set up of "Take any direction without question."
Say, who is training these clones to be soldiers?
No, Padme, the problem is that there are too many people. A senate can't work for thousands of planets.
You know what, I agree Anakin. If a dictator ships works, go for it. Problem is, people suck and a good ruler only comes about once in a thousand years.
Hayden's laughing here is pretty genuine. Doesn't fit the SCENE, but he does seem happy.
Fuck yeah swimming/flying winged whale things. More of those!
Was having Boba Fett really necessary? No. No is the answer.
The Jango guy is a good actor though. If he had just been in the movie, no mention of Boba, it would have been a lot cooler.
Bitches love telekenesis.
Oh god, it's the fireplace scene! SHOT!
They should have just fallen in love without any of the "forbidden" shit. It feels too forced otherwise. Hell, he could have just been smitten and knocked her up. That would be a pretty different galaxy far, far away.
I enjoy the fight with Jango. It doesn't make sense that Obi doesn't use the Force, but it's fun.
Do people really say out loud the things they experience in dreams?
I like the shot of Anakin in the "Vader" pose while meditating. Pretty composition.
I like that Anakin feels he has to go home because he can feel his mother's pain. It is a solid callback (forward?) to Luke's experience on Dagobah. It just needed to be portrayed as honest rather than contrived.
I like that Obi has clearly been trained in hand to hand combat. It's a side of the Jedi we haven't seen before.
Why did you activate your saber, Obi? It's just another effect for the post department.
Oh, yea, Tatooine.
I like how Watto recognized Anakin. It's more subtle than almost everything in the film.
Okay, this chase in the planet ring is awesome Those seismic charges are fucking amazing. Turned it WAY up for those. Sorry neighbors. (Not really.)
Granted, a scene like this should have been Anakin. He is, afterall, the "best pilot", right?
The orb stations/ships on Geonosis remind me a lot of ET's ship. In a good way.
Aaaand we're at the Lars homestead. Feels good. Well, minus 3PO being in some lame silver casing.
It makes me sad that we don't get more interaction between Owen and Anakin. Owen's hatred for Anakin was clear in ANH, and it would have been awesome to see them get to know one another and come to a clear disagreement.
Shit Padme looks fine in these scenes.
Duel of the Fates here? Really? It serves no purpose and fades out too quickly. Shame.
I really like the idea of Obi being a sleuth in these scenes... if only he weren't so bad at it.
A poor introduction to Dooku. This is the man who is supposed to be the replacement for Darth Maul, yet he is not fearsome or intimidating at all. I love Chris Lee, but he worked much better as Saruman.
Good idea for a scene and mostly well shot, but Anakin should have faced a bit more trouble in taking down in the sand people. Well, maybe not trouble, but we should have at least seen more. I would have liked to see him truly rage out. Force powers gone nuts, that kind of thing.
Shmi being delirious is a nice touch. One of the better moments.
Is it really that confusing that Anakin went home, dude? You sent your angst-ridden little Padawan off with his dream girl, and you're surprised he did something crazy? Having dreams about his mom for years, yet when he heads home, you're surprised? Come on, man.
Hayden's performance in the scene is great. His eyes and his posture say a lot. He seems just a bit proud of it, which is nice. Though, Padme's reaction doesn't make a lick of sense. "To be angry is to be human"? Really? Humans murder children when they get angry? They come from a rough neighborhood.
SHOT!
One of the worst parts about this movie is that there really is a semblance of a good movie in here.
Off all the times in this movie, Anakin should have been the one to recommend running off to save Obi. At least that would have lent itself to a "friendship."
People really don't question using a clone army that no one knew about? I get appoving an army, but a clone army that just happens to exist on an uncharted world?
I like the idea of a former Jedi being a character. But not like this. I would prefer it to be more like a Han Solo figure. A rebel with something to prove. Dooku is just a random pawn who has no clear purpose whatsoever.
Dooku telling Obi about a Sith lord is nice. It's a good tactic to tell the truth in a situation like this. This scene is meant to play off of ESB, but there is really no reason for Dooku to be telling Obi this. Does he actually want him to join him? Does Dooku actually hate that he works for the Sith?
FUCK YOU JAR JAR! YOU BURN IN HELL!
This calls back to what I said during TPM. Palpatine takes the powers like Ceasar did. But, as I said, he doesn't in any way earn it. He just comes out of fucking nowhere. His power does not seem scary because we don't really understand it roots. He is too nefarious to be menacing. He's just evil for the sake of being evil rather than appearing to have a real goal.
"I've given up trying to argue with you." What? Are there deleted scened we're missing? It's a funny little "couple moment"... but then, theyve never been a couple.
Oh, awesome, an action scene without ANY merit. This in no way furthers the plot except that, hey, we haven't seen a lightsaber in a while!
Look, we get that 3PO and R2 were the "eyes" of the Ot... but that doesn't mean they had to be in so many scenes in the prequels. It doesn't make sense, and, it actually hurts them as characters. IS NOTHING SACRED, GEORGE!?
Why is his arm stuck? What are they building? Also, what the hell is with the snap-zooms?
An arena battle is a cool idea. Hell, I've thought of filming a Jedi gladiator battle for years. However, this entire scene bothers me for the simple fact that neither Anakin nor Obi use THE GODDAMN FORCE. They can push, pull, jump, run, etc... yet instead they just roll around like morons.
Obi's "Good job" line is excellent. This film needed far more of that.
The Geonosian language is pretty cool.
I love me some Portman midriff... so, I will allow that.
Force... calming? Hmmm....
Jump? I'm not a chick... but I'm pretty sure that would hurt like hell.
No one notices that thousand ships show up? Not even Mr. Sith Lord?
I like the idea of a shit load of Jedi fighting... but it really depresses me that 200 Jedi suck at fighting THAT much.
It is also really clear that the Jedi are just random extras who have NO idea how to handle a sword.
Why does Jango get involved in this at all? He has nothing to gain by fighting these Jedi.
Oh, Kit Fisto, you remembered you could use the Force.
Dude, Obi, that's just an innocent animal that the bad guys forced to attack you You don't need to so ruthlessly kill it.
DEUS EX MACHINA!
Say, where did the Clones get those ships?
Why are the Jedi fighting on the ground? I think we've shown that they suck at fighting droids.
Having the Death Star in the background was a cool choice... until they brought it to the foreground. Audiences really aren't that stupid, George.
You're out of rockets? What about lasers?
"Jedi powers." What a terrible line. Is that really what a 70 year old Jedi would say?
How do you know there's a hangar, Padme?
This is, easily, the worst duel in the saga. The acting, energy, and choreography are terrible. Dooku is supposed to be a fencing master... but he doesn't do a single fencing move. And he also wins by not doing anything. Anakin just drops his guard.
Oh lord, the Yoda saber fight. Let's clear this up right now: Yoda should never use a lighsaber. He is a 900 year old MASTER, a sword should be well behind him. This fight is absurd. How does an 80 year old man defeat a 900 year old Jedi? This should never have happened. I think George thought we'd be impressed with his twirly, spinny shit.. but he doesn't even win. Dooku just stands there and holds him off. Also, Yoda then has a hard time lifting that weird power cylinder... thing. Size matters not, my ass.
Yeah, Padme, use your little laser gun. Good call.
Why is Sidious wearing his good here? Does Dooku not know who it is? I mean, if we know, he should know.
How dare they use Vader's march here. Disgusting.
Anakin and Padme are married. We all know that marriages created from a 2 week relationship last. True love, absolutely.
Well, sorry, I am going to have to do Sith later. I'm fucking tired and, as it turns out, I just can't handle the prequel trilogy on my own. I am weak.
A few technical notes: This movie looked decent on Blu-Ray. This was shot on a digital camera in 2001, which was well before digital cameras were a thing. Because of that, the image is a bit soft and does not hold up the images of today (2012). That isn't to say it was bad, but it was still clear that it wasn't, uh, clear. The real issue here is that they won't really be able to clean this up for the future. Film can always be scanned at a high resolution, but this is trapped in its 1080p form for all time. I suppose they could re-render it entirely, but I doubt they will. Which is fine since this movie is pretty lousy anyways. The sound, however, was top-notch.